LONDON, UK - March 15, 2019:Thousands of students and young people protest in London as part of the youth strike for climate march - Image
PHOTO: Shutterstock.com

Following reports from solicitors and individual campaigners in several parts of the country saying that the police have been asking schools for lists of students taking part in climate strike protests, Netpol has canvassed the opinions of campaigners, asking them how feel about this and what impact it may have on organising and their participation.

We asked 42 students involved in UK Student Climate Network whether this intrusive interest from the police would deter them or others from participating in climate strikes and whether it would make it more difficult to organise around the climate strikes in their schools. We also asked whether they were concerned about how information gathered by the police is used and how they thought schools should respond to requests for students’ names.

Do you feel that this behaviour from the police would deter you or others from participating in climate strikes?

Multiple responses were permitted.

This would not deter me from taking part in climate strikes. 64.1%
It may deter some people from joining in.56.4%
I know students who would not join because of this.51.3%
I am less likely to join in if this happens at my school.12.8%
I would not join because of this.0%
Other5.1%

One student said, “I’d feel more on edge and stressed – and I have the privilege of being white and from a financially stable background, which protects me from some of the worst police violence and aggression”. Another, however, said, “I would be louder in getting others to strike so as to stand up against the police’s actions”.

Do you feel that this behaviour from police would make it more difficult for you or others to organise around the climate strikes in your school?

Only one answer was permitted.

This would not make it more difficult to organise in my school.43.6%
This might make it more difficult to organise in my school.25.6%
This would deter me and/or others from organising in my school.17.9%
I would not feel able to organise in my school because of this.5.1%
Other7.7%

One student told us, “Whilst I would be undeterred, the supportiveness of my teachers may decrease and other students would feel as though protesting was beyond their rights or even unsafe and this would minimise how willing they are to be involved in the climate protests. My school will wish to protect its students from harm and if the police are acting in this way then the school will not want its students to get in trouble or be harmed so it may even try to deter us from organising around the climate strikes so as to keep us ‘safe’”.

Do you have concerns about how this information will be used by the police?

Multiple responses were permitted.

I would like to know how I can find out if I am on a police list.79.5%
I would like more information about how this information will be used by the police.74.4%
I am angry that the police would keep this information about me on file.71.8%
I am worried that the police would keep this information about me on file.48.7%
I have no concerns about how this information will be used by police.2.6%
Other2.6%

How do you think schools should respond to this?

Only one answer was permitted.

I think schools should refuse to hand over this information.92.3%
I have no opinion on how schools should respond.0%
I am not sure.5.1%
I think schools should hand over this information. 0%
Other2.6%

One student told us schools should go beyond refusing to hand over information and should “actively stand up and call out the police for doing this”.

In other comments we received, one young person expressed concerns that targeting of students by the police could “severely impact their chances of being accepted by other schools” and could pose “a severe risk to their education and schooling”.

They added, “Parents send their kids to school to be safe and to learn and to be happy, and parents will undoubtedly be more than just concerned to learn about this kind of behaviour from the police. How will parents know which school to trust if schools are quietly being told to give out private and personal information to the police?”

On the question of the privacy of data, another added, “My school no longer gives student representatives name badges due to the [data protection] act, so something to this extent is very discomforting and it should be within the school’s best interest to protect their students’ data”.

What is clear from these results is that these student campaigners, who are largely familiar with their legal rights, remain determined to take a stand on climate change, but know others for whom police data-gathering will have a chilling effect on their participation in protests.

There is a strong desire, too, to know what happens to any information about their participation in campaigning activities and overwhelming support for headteachers to refuse to hand over lists to the police.

This survey shows that there are genuine concerns amongst students taking part in climate strike protests about infringements on their rights to freedom of assembly and expression that result from unwarranted attention by the police.

A significant number of the young people we spoke to are worried that it will deter some of their classmates from taking part and make it more difficult to organise. They also want to know what happens to lists of names handed over to the police and are looking to schools to protect their privacy.

This is why Netpol is calling on schools to fulfil their legal responsibilities to the young people in their care by refusing to cooperate with demands for “watch lists” of young campaigners.

In doing so, they would have the support of some of their most socially and politically engaged students.